Select Page

Deductibles apply to all types of uninsured/underinsured motorist property damage coverage. Comprehensive, collision, personal injury protection, and uninsured/underinsured motorist bodily injury coverage are all included. There are deductibles on all policies that you must meet before filing a claim.

If your car is damaged in an accident, you usually make a claim with your insurer to cover the cost of repairs. If you have comprehensive coverage, for example, you can directly claim the repair costs from your insurance.

Your deductible is subtracted from the amount of your claim payout before your auto insurance company pays to have the damage repaired. Deductibles for car insurance are usually set in stone, such as $500 or $1,000, and are not susceptible to modification.

If you set your auto insurance deductible improperly, it might cost you a lot of money in the future. Deductibles are perplexing and frustrating for many people, which is natural given the large range of options available. It can be difficult to choose between a high premium and a high deductible when it comes to vehicle insurance.

Understanding the distinctions between low-deductible and high-deductible plans, as well as monthly premiums, will assist you in making the best choice. To begin, you must take into account all important elements, including your financial condition and other relevant circumstances. In this article, we’ve attempted to present you with the most up-to-date and relevant information on vehicle insurance deductibles.

What exactly is a deductible?

Coverage deductibles are necessary for some forms of insurance. In the case of a liability claim, for example, there is no auto insurance deductible. A deductible is a pre-determined sum that you are responsible for paying out of pocket following an accident that is your fault.

Let’s have a look at an example of this. When you were reversing your car, it collided with a fire hydrant, resulting in $3,000 in repair costs. To ensure that the repairs are covered, you must file a collision claim with your motor insurance company.

If you select a $500 deductible, you will be responsible for paying $500 out of pocket, with your insurance provider covering the remaining $2,500.

What are deductibles and claim costs in auto insurance?

The “deductible” is the amount of money paid when filing a claim for an insured loss. In other words, if you are in a car accident and submit a claim, the amount of compensation you receive will be lowered by your insurance deductible.

Your auto insurance deductible is normally a certain amount that you must pay, such as $500. If an insurance adjuster concludes that your claim is worth $6,000 and you have a $500 deductible, your claim will be compensated for $5,500. However, depending on your deductible, not every vehicle accident is worth filing a claim.

Parts and labor for repairing a little scratch in your bumper caused by backing into a tree can cost up to $600. It is preferable to pay for all of the damages yourself. That is, the $100 over and above your $500 deductible. It prevents your auto insurance rates from rising by avoiding submitting a claim, which might raise your premiums.

What are vehicle insurance deductibles and how do they work?

Deductibles for car insurance vary based on the coverage and the driver. When you buy your policy, you can choose your deductible. When comparing vehicle insurance policies, it’s important to think about the deductible alternatives to see which one is best for you.

When seeking rates for car insurance, buyers who want to save money on their coverage might consider upping their deductibles. However, drivers who do so should be aware that if a claim is filed against them, they may have to pay extra money out of pocket.

Assume a repair business estimates that the accident-related damage will cost $5,000 to repair. If your motor insurance coverage has a $500 deductible, the insurer will remove $500 from the $5,000 reimbursement to cover the damage. It implies you’ll get $4,500 to pay the expense of the repair, and you’ll be responsible for the remaining $500.

You can choose your deductible amount when you buy the policy. When you file a claim, you are usually responsible for paying your deductible. It is possible to adjust your deductible, but the change will not affect any claims that have already been filed.

The $500 deductible is the most frequent on automobile insurance premiums. Depending on your insurance company and where you live in the world, your deductible can range from $100 to $1,000 or more.

Which types of auto insurance have deductibles?

Because there are several types of auto insurance coverage, there are also various deductibles based on those policy categories. It’s vital to know how much your vehicle insurance deductible is for each type of policy so you know how much you’ll be responsible for if you file a claim.

Insurance against liability

Liability insurance covers the costs of people who have been hurt as a result of an accident in which you were at fault. Unlike other types of coverage, liability auto insurance does not have a deductible.

Comprehensive Coverage

If your vehicle is damaged due to something other than a collision with another automobile or object, comprehensive coverage reimburses you for the costs. It might entail, among other things, hail damage, colliding with a deer, or replacing a shattered windshield. It will also cover the price of returning items that have been stolen. The deductible for this form of coverage is usually cheaper than the deductible for damage to another vehicle or property as a consequence of an automobile accident.

Collision insurance covers the cost of damages to your vehicle if you are at fault. Let’s say your car was involved in a collision with another vehicle or an item, such as a tree or a structure. In most circumstances, it is the highest deductible available on your auto insurance coverage.

Assume your car collides with another vehicle that is at fault and has proper insurance. In that situation, your vehicle’s damage is covered by the other driver’s insurance coverage. In that case, you would not have to pay a collision deductible.

Personal Injury

A personal injury claim is covered by personal injury protection (PIP) and uninsured motorist coverage. Personal injury protection covers the driver and all passengers in your vehicle’s medical bills. Your expenses are reimbursed if you are hit by an uninsured motorist.

Assume you were in a car accident with another motorist who was at fault, but you lacked insurance or did not have enough insurance to cover all of your losses. This type of coverage isn’t available in every auto insurance policy, and some don’t even cover deductibles.

What is the typical cost of a deductible?

Deductibles vary a lot from one driver to the next. Because when obtaining automobile insurance, buyers can choose from a variety of coverage options with differing monetary limits.

The most frequent deductible amounts for most drivers are $250, $500, and $1,000, respectively. According to MoneyGeek’s research, the average vehicle insurance deductible is roughly $500.

Which deductible amount, modest or high, should you choose?

You should be aware that you will be responsible for a lesser amount of the cost of a vehicle insurance claim, which means you will have to pay a larger premium for your coverage. Furthermore, because you would be accountable for a greater amount of the cost if you submit a claim, a higher deductible will often result in a cheaper premium.

If you already have a car loan, your lender may have stipulated a minimum deductible amount, so double-check before deciding.

Alternatively, there is no “proper” or “wrong” deductible amount; rather, it is a matter of personal preference and comfort level. If you’d rather pay more for car repairs than for insurance, boosting your deductible is a good rule of thumb.

Take the following into consideration:

If the thought of having to pay extra to fix your automobile does not bother you, a large deductible may be a smart option if you submit a claim.

Assume you already have enough money set aside to cover the gap between your repair bill and your insurance claim settlement. In that situation, a high deductible would be a good option.

Let’s say you don’t live in a location where hail, flooding, or animal collisions are common, or you have a long commute in a city. In that instance, you may be less likely to file a claim, so a high-deductible coverage might not be such a bad choice.

What if you can’t afford to pay your deductible on your car insurance?

If your emergency funds are spent and you are unable to pay your deductible, you have numerous options.

You may be able to postpone the repair until you have the necessary finances if you have other forms of transportation or if your automobile is safe to drive. Keep in mind, however, that you must notify your insurer as quickly as possible in order for them to pay your claim.

Look for less expensive alternatives to expensive repairs. Get a few more estimates to see if you can get a better deal on the repair. If you receive the check, you should be able to negotiate a reduced repair fee. Repair shops will sometimes “waive” the deductible, meaning they will do the job for less money than the adjuster projected or determined.

Look for a vehicle insurance deductible payment plan that works for you. Inquire about a deductible payment plan for your auto insurance with your favorite shop, which allows you to spread the expense of your deductible over a period of time. You’ll almost definitely be required to pay interest, but your vehicle should be repaired as quickly as feasible.

The amount of your automobile insurance deductible is completely up to you. The best option for you will be determined by a number of factors, including your driving history, location, financial condition, insurer, and other factors. You may compare quotes from several insurers at varying deductible amounts by using’s helpful tools.

What is the definition of a minimal deductible?

A minimal deductible may be included in your policy. When you wish to save money, you can boost your deductible; but, if your firm has set a minimum deductible, you won’t be able to do so.

Inquire about how your deductible works because some plans offer zero deductibles or deductibles that disappear with time. Look for a coverage with a low minimum deductible or inquire about an insurance with no deductible.

What are the different forms of vehicle insurance deductibles?

There are several forms of automotive insurance to select from, each with a different deductible:

Collision Deductible

If you have collision insurance and your vehicle is damaged after an accident, the amount you pay for repairs is decided by whether you were at fault or accountable for the accident:

Pay the full amount

When you are 100 percent responsible, you must pay the entire amount.

Pay a percentage of the total

You pay a portion of the bill. You are accountable for paying half of your deductible if you are 50 percent at fault.

Total deductibles for the year

You are always liable for paying the entire deductible when submitting a claim under comprehensive insurance.

One element that influences your rate is your deductible; the bigger your deductible, the lower your long-term costs will be. Make sure to double-check with your insurance company to see what kinds of risks are covered.

Should I choose for a low deductible or a high deductible?

Keep in mind that though you’ll be responsible for a lesser amount of the cost of a vehicle insurance claim, you’ll have to pay a higher premium for your coverage. Furthermore, because you would be accountable for a greater amount of the cost if you submit a claim, a higher deductible will often result in a cheaper premium.

If you have a car loan, your lender may have stipulated a minimum deductible amount, so check with them before deciding on one. Alternatively, there is no such thing as a “proper” or “wrong” deductible amount; rather, it is a matter of personal preference and what you are comfortable with.

Raising your deductible is a good rule of thumb to follow; you’d rather pay more for car repairs than insurance. Take the following into consideration:

If the thought of having to pay extra to fix your automobile does not bother you, a large deductible may be a smart option if you submit a claim.

Assume you already have enough money set aside to cover the gap between your repair bill and your insurance claim settlement. In that situation, a high deductible would be a good option.

Assume you don’t live in a location prone to hail, flooding, or animal collisions, or that you don’t have a long trip in a city. In that instance, you may be less likely to file a claim, so a high-deductible coverage might not be such a bad choice.

Decreased deductibles are what they sound like

A “diminishing deductible,” an optional feature offered by some insurance in exchange for being a careful driver, may be available to you. In some circles, it’s also known as a “vanishing” or “disappearing” deductible.

Assume you stay out of automobile accidents and have a spotless driving record. As a result of your good behavior, your insurance will gradually reduce your deductible.

For example, an insurance might give you a $100 annual deductible credit if you keep a clean driving record for a year. If you maintain a perfect driving record for three years, your $500 deductible may be reduced to $300. Your new deductible will be $200 as a result of this.

What is the difference between high deductible and low deductible auto insurance?

When calculating your deductible, consider the following factors:

What is the maximum amount of money you can spend if your automobile is damaged and no longer works? Assume you only have one automobile and rely on it for transportation to and from work. In such instance, a deductible that surpasses the amount in your emergency fund is generally not a good idea.

Your deductible is ignored unless you submit a collision or comprehensive insurance claim. There is no deductible to pay if you bring a lawsuit against another party’s liability insurance.

A low deductible may not be beneficial to you because making a small claim can cause your premiums to climb in the future. They may potentially increase in value beyond the amount you receive. In actuality, unless the damages exceed your deductible by a sufficient amount, you would usually avoid submitting a claim for damages.

For instance, if your deductible is $1,000 and your damages total $1200, you’d probably choose to absorb the $200 rather than risk having your rates raised as a result of making the claim.

The issue is, how much money could you save if you increased your deductible? And, if you had to submit an insurance claim, how long would it take for the premium savings to more than cover the higher costs?

Keep in mind that decreasing your deductible is just one way to save money on vehicle insurance. Consumers should get aware with eight factors of auto insurance that can affect their premiums significantly.

How much money can you save if you increase your auto insurance deductible?

Raising your deductible from $200 to $500 is a good idea. According to the Insurance Information Institute, you may be eligible for a 15 to 30% premium cut, with a 40% premium decrease if your deductible is raised to $1,000.

However, it varies significantly based on the state in which you live, as well as the cost of your insurance after taking into account any additional discounts, your driving record, and the cost of repairing or replacing your automobile. The amount of a discount granted for greater deductibles varies per company.

How can a deductible help you save money?

Despite the fact that a greater deductible implies you must pay a larger share of the claim, most people do not submit claims every year. You could file a claim for each year that you haven’t filed one and save money in the process.

By modifying the deductible, you can customize your insurance coverage to match your individual needs. It is normally not a problem if you can afford a higher rate for a year but then decide you want to cut it. Keep in mind that your monthly payments will alter as well. Your costs may rise if you have a high claim rate.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of having a low auto insurance deductible?

Having a low vehicle insurance deductible might provide you peace of mind, particularly if you’re on a tight budget. Consider how a $500 or $1,000 out-of-pocket expense would have a huge impact on your budget. In that situation, it’s wise to play it safe and choose for a modest deductible, like $250. When it comes to auto insurance, some firms even offer a $0 deductible, which means you’ll never have to pay anything more on top of your usual charges.

You will pay more in monthly premiums if you have a lower deductible. Even so, because your deductible is cheaper, you won’t have to worry if something occurs to your car. If you have a history of colliding with another car in the Starbucks parking lot, it’s a good idea to obtain a low-deductible auto insurance policy.

You should choose a lower deductible if you are leasing or financing your vehicle. You won’t have to worry about deciding on your own because most lease/finance agreements stipulate a deductible of $500 or less.

If you drive an older model or a beater car, your collision and comprehensive coverage may be reduced. There is no insurance coverage and no deductible.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of having a high auto insurance deductible?

What is the most persuasive case for a high auto insurance deductible? You will see a big savings in your monthly premiums.

According to the Insurance Information Institute, raising your deductible from $200 to $500 will save you 15 to 30% on your annual insurance premiums. You may save up to 40% by raising your deductible from $500 to $1,000.

Although these figures appear to be correct, keep in mind that they are merely estimates, and the savings are restricted to accident and comprehensive insurance prices. You’ll need to do some math to see if a high deductible vehicle insurance policy will save you money.

Please try out different deductible amounts using Compare’s free vehicle insurance quotation calculator to see how they effect your premiums and expenditures.

Then double-check your calculations to be sure you’re correct. How long do you think it will take for the money you save each year to cover the cost of your high-deductible insurance policy? Consider the following scenario: you reduce your premiums by $50 per year by raising your deductible from $250 to $500, but you must file a claim.

It will take you five years to save up enough money to equal the amount you spent on the trip. If you choose not to make an insurance claim and instead pay for everything yourself, your insurance premiums may stay lower in the long run.

What is the most cost-effective option? You may compare costs on Try a few different deductibles to see how much you’d save if you went with a $0 deductible instead of a $1,000 deductible, then compare the results. You’ll be able to make the most informed decision possible based on your budget and requirements.


In conclusion, picking the appropriate deductible level depending on your needs and financial conditions will save you hundreds of dollars on your vehicle insurance coverage. Consider the many aspects described in this article and speak with your insurance agent about your alternatives if you’re considering between a $500 or $1,000 vehicle insurance deductible.

If you can’t make your annual or monthly payments, it’s better not to increase your deductible. Instead, do some careful research to see if there are any other ways to reduce insurance prices. Your vehicle insurance agent will be able to evaluate your situation and advise you on the most cost-effective ways to save money.